Athlete of the Year / Scholar-Athlete of the Year Awards
| Year | Male Athlete of the Year | Male Scholar-Athlete of the Year | Female Athlete of the Year | Female Scholar-Athlete of the Year |
| 2006 | Justin Porter – Football/T & F | Andy Hall – Football/Basketball/Golf | Angela Matera – Volleyball/Soccer | Theresa Landwehr – Cross Country/T & F |
| 2007 | Justin Taplin-Ross – Football/Basketball/T & F | TS Reed – Baseball | Heather Erickson – Tennis/T & F | Katie Terrazas – Softball |
| 2008 | Kavon Seaton – Football/T & F
Ryan Swafford – Basketball/T & F |
Derek Legg – Baseball | Kiah Smythe – Tennis/Basketball/T & F | Nicole Matera – Cross Country/Soccer/T & F |
| 2009 | Nick Ross – Basketball/T & F | Noe Ramirez – Cross Country/T & F | Shannon Haas – WaterPolo/Swimming | Karleigh Kaczmarek – Volleyball |
| 2010 | Bryce Rausa – Cross Country/Soccer/T & F | Drew Dalton – Cross Country/T & F | Dynese Adams – Volleyball/Basketball/T & F | Jessica McCarthy – Cross Country/T & F |
| 2011 | Jovonte Slater-Miller – Football/ T & F | Reuben Franklin – Wrestling | Tisha Alyn Abrea – Golf | Alexis Hein – Volleyball |
| 2012 | Corey Whitaker – Football/ T & F
Darion Williams – Football/ T & F |
Davin Guinn – Basketball/T & F | Erika Reddish – Cross Country/T & F | Hannah Evans – Swimming/WaterPolo |
| 2013 | Nick Stevens – Football/Basketball | Porter Reddish – Cross Country/T & F | Serafina Maulupe – Basketball | Madison Hudkins – Swimming |
| 2014 | Wyatt Paterson – Football/Wrestling/Tennis | Aaron Ruth – Football/Soccer | Michelle Norman – T & F | Angie Phenbenjakul – Swimming |
| 2015 | Jamie Nunley – Football/Basketball | Harrison Morgan – Football/Wrestling/T & F | Sydney Romero – Softball | Lovie Burleson – T & F |
| 2016 | Michael Norman – T & F | Rachuan Wagstaff – Football/Wrestling | Brittney Reed – Basketball
Amanda Van Buren – T & F |
Alli Kim – Golf |
| 2017 | Javelin Guidry – Football/T & F | Cole Dubots – Football/T & F | Emma Vanderhyden – Tennis/Soccer | Josie Guinn – Soccer |
| 2018 | Edgar Villa – Cross Country/T & F | Elisha Guidry – Football/Basketball/T & F | Gabriella Stoll – Basketball | Alyson Bean – Golf |
| 2019 | Willie Coleman – Cross Country/T & F | Luke Noon – Soccer | Chelsea Duran – Volleyball/Soccer | Peyton Candaele – Cross Country/T & F |
| 2020 | Raquel Wagstaff – Football/Wrestling | Jacob Nichols – Soccer | Makayla Fick – Cross Country/T & F | Mariss Levine – Soccer |
| 2021 | Darius Hill – Basketball/T & F | Noah Murasmith – Cross Country/T & F | Molly Wilson – Volleyball | Reinna Gabriel – Soccer |
| 2022 | Jack Pederson – Football/Baseball | Brandon Calderon – Cross Country/T & F | Mariyah Casados – Wrestling | Gabriella Etmans – Lacrosse |
| 2023 | Gary Dotson – Basketball | Ty Bradley – Wrestling | Claire Little – Volleyball | Taylor Jarrett – Lacrosse |
| 2024 | Brody Guinn – Football/Basketball/T & F | Ryan Vergara – Football/LaCrosse | Aspen Fears – T & F
Alyssa Alumbres – T & F |
Lauren Sammon – Golf |
